New Year’s resolutions: why they don’t work and what to do instead

by Dec 28, 2020Coaching

Is that time of year again, when you look at yourself in the mirror, grab your brand new fancy planner and begin to write down your new year’s resolutions.

You feel excited to  finally lose weight, or change job, or start that business, so you apply yourself diligently for a few weeks and then…

…then you quit, just like you did last year, and the year before that.

Read also: “Why we quit: 4 reasons and 4 strategies to help you”

I know you don’t want to admit it, but that’s exactly what happens. The only consolation I can offer you is that you’re not alone in this!

In fact, the majority of people who create a new year’s resolutions list abandon it before the end of January. Most of my clients come to me exactly because they’re tired of repeating the same cycle over and over again without making any real changes.


But why do we do this to ourselves?


Why do we keep on doing something every single year, when we know it never worked before, hoping this time it will be somehow different?

Well, we all have our own personal reasons, but mainly what all humans have in common is the inability to easily change. It’s very hard to change our mind, our habits and our behaviors, so we simply live the only way we’ve learned to, without even questioning if it makes any sense at all.

If you’re still reading because you didn’t get triggered by this first paragraph, I salute you and I invite you to stick with me to understand why new year’s resolutions rarely work.

This way you can choose to correct your course of action and mark 2021 as the year you finally did that thing you’ve been talking about since 1995 (just kidding, you were only a toddler then! Let’s say since 2015!)





scritta change - cambia per i propositi per l'anno nuovo

Reasons why they don’t work:

1- You repeat them without reflecting


Writing the same list of goals, new habits or intentions every year without reflecting on what went wrong the year before is pointless, yet most people do just that. Not taking time to assess what prevented you from keeping your commitments will result in the same outcome you get every year.

Related article: “Your choices determine your life”

pila di libri accatastati per propositi per l'anno nuovo

2 – You have way too many


When friends or clients share their new year’s resolutions lists with me, I get overwhelmed by the amount of things they’re planning to start, stop, change, get rid of or achieve all at once. Overestimating your time and energy or underestimating the complexity of certain projects is another common mistake that can lead to exhaustion and quitting.

3 – You expect outer change without inner work


Expecting that this will be the year when you finally ask for and get that promotion you long for without overcoming self-doubt, insecurity and low self esteem is a bit unrealistic.

Unless you change your mindset and beliefs around what is possible for you and what you deserve it’s unlikely that you’ll magically find the courage to speak to your boss if you never could in the past.

question mark

4 – You use the same approach every year


For example, every year you “attack “your yearly resolutions by working on them incessantly for days until you collapse (literally or figuratively) and then quit out of exhaustion (see number 2). Or maybe you’ve been trying to lose weight for years by running and it just doesn’t seem to happen, but you persist hoping that this year somehow it will.


5 – Your “why” isn’t strong enough


I promised myself I wasn’t going to quote Simon Sinek anymore (see? My new year resolution didn’t work!), yet here I am once again! By the way, I love you, Simon!

I don’t think there’s anyone left on this planet who isn’t familiar with Simon’s “why” but knowing about it and apply it to yourself are two different things.

The point is that if the reason why you’re trying to start, stop or achieve something isn’t strong enough, you won’t make it. This is why is super important to be honest with yourself and only go after what matters to you and avoid falling for trends or copying friends.


Related article: “Turning your passion into a business: is it a good idea?”

Now let’s see what to do instead!

1 – Reflect on what happened last year


How did it go? Did you end up sticking to your resolutions or not?

What got in your way? What can you do to prevent that from happening again? What are you going to do differently this time?

These are some of the questions I would ask you if you were my client.

Read what some of my clients say about me!

Try and answer honestly and take it from there. When I say “honestly”, I mean without blaming it on other people or outer circumstances.

I know sometimes it’s exactly what happened (you wanted to start exercising regularly but you broke a leg), but that isn’t always the case, especially when the same resolution/goal/intention is missed and then repeated every year.

scritta change - cambia per i propositi per l'anno nuovo

2 – Pick one major and one minor resolution


This technique works every single time! Instead of writing a long list of resolutions and then quitting because it’s just too much (see number 2 in the previous part), pick a major and a minor one.

For example, if your main focus is having a healthier lifestyle don’t say you will quit drinking, run 5 miles every day, meditate, do yoga, become vegan and go to sleep at 9pm!

Pick the one habit that you think will create the greater impact (for example run 5 miles daily) and a smaller one that will be easy to keep (maybe go to sleep at 9pm?).

Read also: “You can create the life you want”


3 – Try a different approach


I know it may seem counter intuitive, but you have no idea of how many people insist on going about it the same way every single year!

Investing in stocks hasn’t helped you saving more money? Try hedge funds! Keto diet didn’t make you lose any weight? Try intermittent fasting!

If you seriously and consistently apply yourself every single year and still get no significant results, it’s time to try something new!

segnale stradale che dice super helpful - utile per i propositi per l'anno nuovo

4 – Focus on a “theme”


This is a different way to embrace yearly resolutions and it’s also very simple to put into practice. Instead of creating the usual list of habits to change or intentions to follow, you focus on a single “theme”.

This means you have to decide what’s going to have priority in your life for the entire year and then make choices that will support that.

Let’s say that you choose to focus on personal growth. What you’ll have to do is commit to behaviors that will promote it and support it, for example you will sign up for a new course, read at least 10 books or work with a life coach.

This strategy is incredibly successful because it helps you define what truly matters to you in this particular moment of your life, rather than trying to do too many things all together.

It’s also very flexible, because it allows you to select the best course of action as you go along, instead of sticking to the only options you’re aware of in the beginning of the year.

Related article: “Get out of your comfort zone”

5 – Get help!


I will never ever get tired of repeating it!

Do you know what my clients tell me after they start working with me?

“Why didn’t I do this before!?”

They regret wasting so much time and energy or giving up on some goals only to find out all they needed was a little professional help!

So, what do you say? Shall I save you a spot?

“Here with you every step of the way”

Latest articles


You can create the life you want

You can create the life you want

2020 has undoubtedly forced us to look at ourselves and our lives in a different, more profound way. Many clients, friends and connections all around the world are telling me how they’re painfully realizing that they’re not as happy as they thought they were. Choices...

read more
Your choices determine your life

Your choices determine your life

Have you ever noticed how people who complain about their life or a specific situation they’re in often seem to think that external or random causes only are responsible for their problems? They don’t even entertain the possibility that the quality of their life has...

read more
Get out of your comfort zone!

Get out of your comfort zone!

How many times have you heard the expression “get out of your comfort zone”? But most of all, are you sure you know what it truly means? Let’s start from the beginning. Your comfort zone is that lovely place where you need to make no effort at all to function in any...

read more


This is what some of my clients say about me. Thank you!

Carlo Alestra

Chiara is a very valuable professional. The journey with her was extremely inspiring and thought-provoking. If you’re looking for a coach who can guide you on a path of change or focus on your goals, she is the perfect partner with whom to engage and find the right keys to face your challenges. More than recommended, a certainty!

Carlo Alestra

Agile Leader

Francesco Marcelli Flori

Chiara is a very empathetic and knowledgeable person. With her I embarked on a mentoring path that helped me clarify many doubts I had as a new coach. After this path I gained confidence and Chiara encouraged me in the right way to get my business off the ground, respecting my personality and goals.

Francesco Marcelli Flori

Life Coach

Max Mars

I found the journey with Chiara very inspiring. I appreciated the freedom of the path, which started with a precise direction and then took unexpected but extremely useful evolutions. I highly recommend it to those who want to approach coaching even without having a specific destination in mind. Enjoy the journey, Chiara is great company.

Max Mars

Reporting Specialist

Marco Zara

Excellent Professional! I have created a new path of growth that is now not limited to the now, but is part of my work and I have carved out a space for everything, thinking by priority and not by urgency as it helped me to understand.
I have gained in serenity, I feel much more confident and I know what goals I need to pursue and with what kind of commitment.

Marco Zara

General Manager

Patricia Padilla

After working with Chiara, I was able to identify my personal skills. She helped me get to know myself better and address personal challenges and dilemmas. Chiara brings positivity, solid advice and professionalism to her work.
Best of all, I felt I was talking to a wise friend. She is incredibly approachable and friendly, and I look forward to working with her again in the future. She has the ability to connect easily, and that’s why I would recommend Chiara to anyone.
Very grateful and lucky to have found her!
Thank you for coaching me!

Patricia Padilla

E- Commerce Manager

Paola Bianchi

I found Chiara by chance, surfing on internet. I still remember that day. I’ve always been intrigued by life coaching, but at the same time I was a bit sceptical about the results.
Anyway, as soon as I met Chiara during our discovery call, I realised she was an extraordinary coach and person too.

My (first) round of sessions with her has just come to an end: during these 5 months we’ve worked together on different matters. She’s guided me to ask myself the right questions to get clear on my goals; she’s helped me challenge some of my personal traits that often contribute to unvoluntarily sabotage my own plans and she’s supported me during the darkest moments of my life changing project.

Chiara is the perfect life coach: kind and sweet, yet motivating and energetic. With every word she said and  every piece of advice she gave me I felt the immense passion she has for her job,  her committment to satisfy her “clients” and a real desire to see them succeed.

I’m sure this will only be a break and that we’ll see each other again very soon.”


Paola Bianchi

Francesca Fatichenti

“Chiara supported me with kindness, listening and passion.She’s always been available, even in between sessions. Thank you for everything!”

Francesca Fatichenti


Linda Puglisi

Going on a coaching path with Chiara was incredibly stimulating and regenerating in a delicate phase of my professional life in which I had to question my work and redefine my future career goals. Chiara’s uniqueness as a coach, in addition to being extremely professional, lies in her extraordinary empathy and her ability to establish a relationship of trust with her clients. Chiara is a coach and an authentic professional and was able to transmit passion, courage and motivation to me thanks to a pragmatic approach, focused on practical steps that are never an end in themselves. Thanks to her, I had the opportunity to focus on my future professional goals and create a plan for their effective realization. Chiara has always been genuinely interested in my growth and has really helped me understand how to be a resource for myself and not an obstacle. His questions opened me to new ideas and perspectives and charged me with a new creative energy.
I would recommend Chiara as a coach to acquaintances and not just for the uniqueness of her approach, empathic and authentic, and her genuine interest in the personal fulfillment of her clients, qualities that are difficult to find in such fast professional contexts in which the human aspect is relational often takes a back seat. Heartfelt thanks Chiara for this journey and for opening my eyes.

Linda Puglisi

Human Resources Manager

Fedy Charlie

Chiara was crazy, an excellent professional and a person of heart. It helped me to make sense and above all to ask myself the right questions. I will definitely need her again in the future. Absolutely recommended!

Fedy Charlie

GDO Manager

Ferruccio pastore

“Working with Chiara has been a revealing experience. I had the chance to uncover sides of myself I had never considered before and I also worked on my own potential, which I had been unable to recognize, because I was clouded by negative thoughts.

I never felt judged, and I could talk freely about what was making feel confused. Chiara was also very patient and available even in between sessions if I wanted to reach out to her. Something worth noting is her flexible approach, meaning that she was able to understand what I needed in each moment and therefore to adapt to it.

When I started the sessions, I was deeply confused about various aspects of my life. The first goal was getting some clarity, then we started working towards the goals that emerged during the sessions. I’m glad I manage to unravel those intricated thoughts that had been with me for a while and I also feel full of energy, because I have goals to achieve.

I definitely recommend Chiara, simply because I got so many benefits, some of which become evident even at the end of the program. “

Ferruccio pastore

Teacher and Trainer, London, UK

Alessandra Mudu

“Working with Chiara has been a stimulating and enriching experience. Chiara has been a valuable ally during a transition, fully present even in between sessions.

I really appreciated being able to work on what was coming up in the moment, without forcing things, yet remaining goal oriented.

As a result of working with Chiara I gained a clearer perspective over what I was going through and what I had to let go; I took a break, processed the end of a phase in my life and started over with renewed awareness.

Chiara is open and transparent, she helped me see things from a distance and explore what needed to be healed. Anyone would benefit from working with her and I highly recommend her to all those who tend to challenge themselves. Coaching is for you if you want to take your own personal development to a new level.”

Alessandra Mudu

Digital Marketer, Barcelona, Spain

Khuloud kalthoum

“Chiara is a truly exceptional coach!

Working with her feels like sitting with a good friend and having a heart- felt conversation.
She helped me prepare for my TEDx talk and better understand my “why”.
After each session, I not only got valuable takeaways, but also felt uplifted and motivated to take concrete actions.

Her questions opened my eyes to new possibilities and ideas and her guidance and feedbacks helped me structure my TEDx talk into an informative, inspiring and entertaining narrative.

I’ve already recommended Chiara to my friends, because even in this global economy world, it’s hard to find a good coach, who genuinely cares about you and seeks to provide values before

Khuloud kalthoum

Entrepreneur, TEDx Speaker - Braga, Portugal


    © Chiara Monaci Life & Business Coach | IVA/VAT Number: 03735500120
    Profession regulated in accordance with italian law 4/2013 | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy
    × How can I help you?